The Easiest Sourdough Discard Bread You'll Ever Make!

This post may contain affiliate links.

If you have a sourdough starter, then chances are you'll have a bit of sourdough discard from time to time - depending on how often you feed it.

Baking true sourdough bread is certainly rewarding, but with our busy lives, we don't always have time for a 2 to 3 day process, right?

So I've created the easiest sourdough discard bread you'll ever make - seriously it's so so simple!

Easiest sourdough discard bread ever

This recipe is perfect if you're still building your sourdough starter, but you really want to bake bread.

Make This Sourdough Discard Bread In Under 2 Hours!

You can make this easy sourdough discard bread within 2 hours if your house is particularly warm. It does use a little commercial yeast - but you will still get some of the sourdough tang from your discard.

If your house is a little cooler, it will take a little longer for the dough to double. Mixing the ingredients takes just seconds!

Experiment With Different Flours

I often make this bread in the evening so I can have a loaf ready for our eggs in the morning. I can knock it out super fast and my kids love to eat it. It's also a great way to experiment with different flours.

While it's super fast to make it from baker's (bread or high protein) flour (AP and plain flour will also work), you could supplement some of the 450g of flour with rye, spelt or even whole wheat.

If you are using different flours, I recommend holding a little of the water back while mixing. It's much easier to add more if you need to, than take it away (or have to add more flour if the mix is too wet).

An Easy Way To Use An Immature Sourdough Starter

This easy sourdough discard bread will also work for you if your starter is not quite ready to start baking true sourdough bread. The commercial yeast will create the rise that is lacking in your sourdough starter.

If you're having trouble with your sourdough starter, you'll find some tips to boost your starter here. You can also join our Facebook Group for sourdough bakers.

You'll find more ideas to use your sourdough discard here as well as a sourdough discard sandwich loaf recipe here.

Sourdough Made Easy Ebook

Extend The Rise

If you don't want to bake your bread immediately once it's risen, you can pop it in the refrigerator for up to 24 hours. Just put the whole bowl in the fridge, covered with a plastic bag or some cling wrap to stop it drying out.

This is a great idea if you want to have it freshly baked for dinner for example or when you first wake up.

When you want to bake it, let it sit out on the kitchen counter for around 30 minutes before it goes in the oven (so take it out when you turn on the oven to preheat).

Want To Give Your Sourdough Discard Loaf A Flavor Boost?

You can add lots of different flavor combinations to this sourdough discard loaf. It's up to you whether you go sweet or savory. Some of my favorite ways to add flavors to this loaf include:

  • Jalepeno Cheddar
  • Bacon & Cheese
  • Olives (you can use whatever olives you love)
  • Chocolate chips and orange zest
  • Cranberries and walnuts
  • Raisins and cinnamon for a fruit loaf

It's best to add the flavors to the dough when you first mix it, that way you can leave it alone to rise rather than have to disturb it to add in the flavors.

Handling The Dough

This sourdough discard loaf can be quite a sticky dough. The stickiness will really depend on the consistency of your starter and how wet you choose to make it. But it's certainly not impossible to work with and is one of the most baked recipes in my Facebook Group!

With a little flour and a dough scraper, you should be able to shape it into a roundish shape. It doesn't need to be perfect, it's a rustic type of bread. If you have a bread lame or razor blade, you can score the top to encourage it to spring up in the oven.

If you're looking for a sandwich loaf recipe, you might like this sourdough discard sandwich loaf.

The dough of this discard loaf is very sticky, but it's still possible to shape and score it.

Bake Your Discard Bread In A Dutch Oven

To get the best results for your sourdough discard bread, bake it in a Dutch Oven. It keeps the steam inside the pot and enables your bread to get the rise before the crust starts to harden. Keep the lid on your Dutch Oven for the first 30 minutes of your bake, then take it off for the last 10 minutes to give it some crunch and colour. Just like baking true sourdough, the Dutch Oven really is a game changer.

If you love this recipe, you'll enjoy making this sourdough pane di casa bread. It is a lovely rustic sourdough you can enjoy in just a few hours.

Easy Sourdough Discard Bread

Looking for ways to use your sourdough discard - this is the bread recipe you need! It's simple, tasty and ensures your sourdough starter creates no waste.
4.40 from 564 votes
Prep Time 2 hours
Cook Time 40 minutes
Total Time 2 hours 40 minutes
Servings 1 Loaf
Calories 1647 kcal

Equipment

  • Mixing Bowl
  • Digital Scales
  • Dutch Oven

Ingredients  

  • 450 g Bread Flour 
  • 360 g Water Warm
  • 10 g Salt
  • 7 g Instant Yeast or Rapid Yeast
  • 100 g Sourdough Discard unfed sourdough starter

Instructions 

  • Take a clean ceramic or glass bowl and add your flour, warm water, instant yeast, salt and sourdough discard.
  • Use a wooden chopstick or end of a wooden spoon to gently bring all the ingredients together into a shaggy dough. You don't need to it be fully smooth, just ensure that all of the flour is wet.
  • Cover the bowl in cling film and set it somewhere warm for 1 - 2 hours. It really depends on the temperature of your house with this one. If your house is warm, 1 hour will be plenty. In the depths of winter or with air con, you may need more than 2 hours. You just want it to double in size, no more or it won't rise in the oven.
  • Around 45 minutes before you want to put your bread into the oven, you'll need to put a dutch oven into the oven and preheat it to around 220C/430F.
  • Once your dough has doubled in size, grab a piece of parchment paper and lay it out on your counter. Sprinkle on a few tablespoons of rice flour or fine semolina flour (this is just so that the dough doesn't stick to your hands).
    NOTE - If you are wanting to put your bread in the refrigerator to bake another time (usually within 24 hours) then just pop the cling film over the bowl of doubled dough and put in the fridge. You don't need to do anything to the dough before it goes in.
  • Scoop your dough out with your hands - if it's particularly wet it's perfectly fine to pour it onto the paper.
    If it's not too wet, use the flour and your finger tips to gently bring it into a round shape - you will need to pull each side over each other to do this. If your dough is too wet - don't fret, just try and bring it into some kind of shape without getting too messy.
  • Score your dough if you're able to - otherwise just leave it and it will open up naturally in the oven.
  • Carefully take your dutch oven out of the oven and remove the lid. Use the parchment or baking paper as a handle to gently place your discard bread inside the pot and put the lid back on.
  • Bake in the oven, with the lid on for 30 minutes at 220C/430F. Then remove the lid of the pot and bake for a further 10 minutes at 200C/390F. Remove the bread from the oven and allow to cool on a wire rack.
  • Try to let it cool for at least an hour before cutting it. It will still taste great if you cut it hot, but it's so much easier to cut if you let it cool!

Nutrition

Calories: 1647kcal Carbohydrates: 329g Protein: 57g Fat: 8g Saturated Fat: 1g Sodium: 3906mg Potassium: 518mg Fiber: 13g Sugar: 1g Vitamin A: 9IU Vitamin C: 1mg Calcium: 83mg Iron: 4mg
Tried this recipe?Share your creation with us @ThePantryMama or tag #thepantrymama!

Share the sourdough love!

Recommended

4.40 from 564 votes (468 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating





233 Comments

  1. Hi
    I use a steam convection oven. I usually do about 50% steam At 425F when doing bread if it is not on an automatic function.
    I do not put a lid on because the lid is to encourage a steam like cooking and mine oven released the steam. , but I do pre heat the crock up first then add the artisan bread. I haven’t made the starter from this site yet. I am going to get a scale and see if that makes a difference
    Any other steam convection oven people on here with suggestions of what they do.
    Thanks
    Anne

    1. A scale makes a difference! I was skeptical but it’s amazing the difference! I have a cheap one from Walmart and it works just fine!

    2. Never made sour dough bread before. This sounds silly but I don’t know how to make the sourdough discard

      1. 5 stars
        I love this recipe! It’s a tasty way to use up discard, easy to make, & versatile too. I have used it as a base for cheddar-jalapeño, blueberry-lemon, & cranberry-orange discard breads. I share this recipe frequently with others looking for quick & easy discard recipes.

    1. I don't have a cast iron dutch oven. Is there any alternative? Being seniir, I find those pots too heavy plus storage is an issue if I want it in a convenient location for when I bake bread

    1. I have used AP flour many times for this recipe. It changes the texture a bit, but I still think it is fantastic! (especially with cinnamon and raisins added)

    2. I do, but I use much less water, all purpose doesn’t hold like bread flour- the first two loaves were with a VERY wet mix .. so I use 300g of water but keep everything else the same!

    3. 5 stars
      I have to say, I have made this recipe over 100 times. It is my go to when I don’t have two days to bake sourdough and need a quick option in two hours. It is always delicious and SO easy.

    1. Baker's Flour is a high protein strong white flour used in Bakeries. I'm in Australia so the equivalent in the US would be Bread Flour yes.

    2. 5 stars
      Oh my! This was positively delicious! I followed your recipe exactly as written. I will be making this again, and again,and again. Thank you!

    3. I cooked at recommended time and it was still gummy on the inside. Any way to tell when it’s cooked all the way through without using a thermometer?

    1. This one definitely needs to be enclosed. Any pot with a lid is fine as long as it can cope with higher temperatures.

        1. sorry what is the English system of measurements. I only bake in grams because it's accurate and gives a consistent result, unlike volume measurements 🙂

          1. Hi, I'm new to all this and wonder if I leave the dough in the fridge for 24 hours to bake the following morning, do I bake straight from the fridge or have it come to room temperature? Thank you.

          2. Using your discard sourdough what amount of bread flour can I replace with either Einkorn or Einkorn AP flour?

          3. 5 stars
            Just want to put in a good word for using grams and a kitchen scale. I recently bought one to use to bake sourdough and I will never go back to cups. You can end up having to wash three or four measuring cups in the English system (cups, spoons). A kitchen scales with a tare function has transformed my baking.

    2. I was told by another lady that the crock from your crockpot could be used and if the lid isn’t oven safe for high temps you can use a cookie sheet. I would make sure the crock can handle higher heat.

  2. Hello! Thanks so much for this recipe! I have to admit I was doubting myself when the dough finished proofing it was a sticky shaggy mess! However, I was able to shape and score it and it looks AMAZING after the bake! This is a keeper for sure!

    1. 5 stars
      Just baked my very first loaf of bread and I am so thrilled! It was beyond yummy! This recipe is great! I will say I needed to bake it a little longer than the recipe said. Only other complaint is that my white Dutch oven turned brown.. not sure why! But everyone loved the loaf!

    1. 4 stars
      When i have a dough that's too wet to score with a knife or lame -i just snip it with scissors, making 3 or 4 connected cuts to end up with a long arc. Works great.

      Really liked this recipe, thanks for posting. '

      1. Reading this idea while mine is baking so too late for me, but what a great suggestion. I have to admit, my dough going into the oven was a sticky mess, so I came to the comments looking for hope that it will work out. Thanks all for the reassurance. Looking forward to tasting it. The dough (stuck to my fingers) was delicious.

      2. 5 stars
        Reading this idea while mine is baking so too late for me, but what a great suggestion. My dough going into the oven was a sticky mess, but it came out really good! I have a lot of trouble fitting a 3 day sourdough process into my busy life. This was not the perfect loaf, but honestly it was so good I may adopt this as our everyday bread. The only issue will be keeping up with my sons who scarfed down two loaves of this within a couple hours.

        1. 4 stars
          Absolutely love this recipe- quick, easy, and so delicious!

          Like others, I need to extend the cooking time to get to 200 degrees to prevent undercooked, gummy center. Typically about 25-30 mins for the uncovered portion of the bake time.

          With this minor adjustment it is just fabulous!

    2. 5 stars
      Sarah, I refrigerate it in a bowl with generous a amount semolina (or rice flour, so it doesn't stick) over a cloth and cover it for at least a couple of hours before baking it and makes it much easier to score...LOVE this recipe so much!
      Kate, THANK YOU for sharing this ...you are a baking genius! <3

  3. This recipe was so quick and fuss free. Great for busy workdays — I just made the dough in the morning and put it in the refrigerator and baked it a little before dinner. I’m always on the lookout for practical recipes for my sourdough discard and this was perfect. Thanks.

    1. If I’ve dried my discard out on paper, can I/must I re-constitute it for this recipe? If so, how much water to re-constitute?

    2. 3 stars
      My loaf looked beautiful when it was done. But I found the dough too wet and sticky to work with. I ended up covering the bottom with flour. I think next time I may just put it straight into the Dutch oven on the parchment paper instead of tying to shape it first.

  4. I am wondering how I would double the recipe. Could I bake a double recipe in one dutch oven or would I need two dutch ovens to bake two separate loaves?

  5. I made this bread because we wanted homemade bread but I had not fed my starter in a few days. It absolutely is the easiest and best tasting of all my recipes. Perfect crust. Perfect crumb. Very good as sandwich bread. Excellent recipe ❤️❤️❤️👍🏻

    1. 5 stars
      I just came across this recipe today. I didn't have any fast action yeast, so replaced it with 15g fresh yeast. I used 100g of my starter, that had been sitting neglected and unfed in my fridge for months
      (I originally came here, to see if it could be saved!)
      The bread came out looking, smelling & tasting beautiful. I wish I could post a picture!

  6. I love the results. My bread was with a great consistency and crust. I su Dea Cluche instead of a Dutch oven and the results were great !!!

  7. I've made this recipe twice and really love it!. I live at high altitude (7,000 feet) and it worked perfectly with the exception that is was super wet so I could not score it but that worked fine. Both times I made it I checked the internal temp at 40 minutes and it was about 195F degrees. I baked longer it in 5 minute intervals checking the temp and it never got above 200 F degrees, but I baked until it was golden, which was about 15 more minutes.
    However, the second time I made it I remembered to turn down the oven, still had to bake it another 15 minutes, and it was a little gummy in the middle (and we did not wait the whole hour that time). I think I read that at high altitude oven temps should be higher so I will try that next time.

    Regardless, love this recipe! Thank you!!

      1. Hello
        Is it possible to use some whole wheat or the flour in place of some of the white flour? If so would you know the ratios? TIA

  8. This was amazing! My entire family loved it! My son took one bite and said, "This is better than Whole Foods!" Super easy and much faster than my other bread recipes. I was a bit concerned because it was so wet after the first rise, but it came out perfect! I didn't endure cooking it for the last ten minutes because I use a cooking thermometer and it was already at 200 degrees. I usually take it out at 170, but this was perfect!

  9. This is my favorite bread! I have been adding extra flavors with great success. I want to try olive oil and rosemary but am nervous about the oil making it more loose. Any tips?

  10. Hi, I gave a question on sourdough discard. It seems discard starts from day 3 onwards.
    1. Do we keep all the discard together in same bottle and just keep stacking on daily discard ?
    2. Do I need to feed these discards ?

    Sorry but I really needed to ensure I understand this process as I truly want to bake sourdough bread for its benefits.

  11. This is the best soft loaf recipe I’ve found. Can I make it with active starter and leave out added yeast please? Linda

      1. How much active starter would you use in place of instant yeast and do you need to adjust any water ratio when doing that substitution? Excited to try this recipe!

      2. This recipe is FABULOUS! I’ve already made 5 loaves, and have requests for more! Quick question… Is it bad to keep it in the fridge for longer than 24 hours?

        1. This is the loaf I always bake. We love it!
          I add 1/3c each pumpkin and sunflower seeds and rolled oats. I soak them an hour and only add 350g water.

      3. 5 stars
        I was nervous while mixing that I missed a step or misread something because of how simple it was. Start to finish I made a loaf of bread in less than 2 1/2 hours (the dough doubled very quickly in the warm kitchen from the preheating oven) and it’s fantastic. I may never bother the long process of making traditional sourdough again. Thanks

  12. I'm trying this sourdough discard recipe for the first time and am anxiously waiting for the results. It rose nicely but was too wet and sticky to form anything resembling a ball on the parchment. Is this normal? I've had great success with regular sourdough loaves.

  13. 4 stars
    Thank you for this recipe! I tried my best to follow it exactly, but I only had all purpose flour on hand. It was very sticky and wet ao i had trouble shaping it. I was surprised to see it had risen all the way to the lid when i uncovered it for the last few mins in the oven. It looked awesome, but when i sliced it, there was a hollow part in the middle. Any ideas where I went wrong? I live in a very hot, humid, tropical country (the philippines). Thank you!

  14. 5 stars
    Loved it! Tried this recipe today. I only had 70 g of discard starter but still turned out amazing! Great recipe!

  15. 5 stars
    I added grated cheese and Italian herbs. I added a tad more flour and gave it a quick shaping, I was worried I’d bust my bubbles but WOW! Beautiful oven spring! With minestrone soup, I died and went to Heaven. 😍

    1. Is this as good for our tummies as a traditional sourdough bread? And can this be baked in a regular loaf pan? Thanks for your wonderful site!

  16. 5 stars
    Hi, i tried making this morning. The crumbs looks nice but ok to eat but it’s actually a bit gummy.

  17. Boo! I should have read the comments. I don't have a dutch oven. I guess I'm goint to try loaf pans unless you have another suggestion.

  18. I'm excited to try this. TWO questions 1. What size Dutch oven is required? (My Dutch oven holds a little over 8 US quarts of liquid, 64 to 72 ounces) 2. Do you have
    measurements for this recipe in Standard Measurements, not metric? Would save me time trying to convert them if you already have them converted. Thanks much, can't wait to use my discarded sourdough starter!

  19. 4 stars
    recipe worked out great! great for a quick artisan loaf! i used 300 g white bread flour and 150 g of whole wheat flour.

  20. This was so easy that I wasn’t sure it would be good. So glad I was wrong! Yes, it was a very wet dough, and not real easy to score, but it rose incredibly and tasted amazing. Thanks for the wonderful recipe!

  21. 5 stars
    Turned out better than expected. Taste was spot on! Texture and crumb were open and light. Really impressed with the bread considering the dough was super wet. I did my best not to over handle. Just did a few small blobs for loaves. Was too wet to score but no worries, they looked great. Thank you for the recipe! I’ll be making again

    1. I am very frustrated with the wetness and stickiness of this dough. I had a horrible time shaping and there was no way to even attempt scoring it. I put it in the oven. Will wait and see if I use this recipe again.

  22. What’s the best way to make this recipe when my starter comes straight out refrigerator? Do I feed it first or just start the recipe out of refrigerator? It’s been in refrigerator for 4 weeks.

  23. 4 stars
    I made this a while back and didn't love it. It was SUPER sour (which I like a sour sourdough but it was too much even for me!) probably because my discard is usually pretty old by the time I get around to using it. I also think I overproved it - be warned this dough grows A LOT, even in the fridge (I did a cold proof because I wanted to retard the process a bit and make the dough easier to handle). I think this recipe is likely better if you're using fresh discard and I might even suggest pulling back on the commercial yeast a bit. It think it'd also taste better with some other flours besides white bread flour - I think rye, spelt, etc. match well with super sour bread.

  24. I want to try this with whole wheat/grain flour. Do I need to adjust any ingredient quantities (more liquid? Less flour?)?

  25. 4 stars
    This was a very tasty pancake. It really wants some folds to help with the structure. There was plenty of time to do a few folds. One more try! This time with a few different flours to enhance flavor. It is nice to sometimes speed the process. Thanks for the experience.

  26. I love this recipe and usually make it to give to people. I always use fed starter though. Also, I increase the flour to 460g and reduce the water to 340g. It's not nearly as sticky and turns out great. I use a mix of bread flour and Eikorn flour. Wonderfully delicious!

  27. 5 stars
    So glad to have found this recipe! The discards we really bugging me, and there is only just so much composting I wanted to be doing. I added one set of stretch and folds but that was the only change I made. It’s the first time I’ve gotten a crust to blister up !

  28. 5 stars
    Thank you so much. Just don’t have the time for traditional sourdough. Mixed in the bread machine on dough. Baked in old cast iron Dutch oven on the grill. Fantastic. Burned the bottom a bit but will adjust the grill and add baking stone under pot next time. Scraped the burn off. Delicious. Making again this weekend. Decreased water just a bit.

    1. I heard using a cookie sheet under the Dutch oven helps prevent the bottom burning. I’m going to try this recipe and this recommendation today.

  29. 5 stars
    This recipe is fast and easy and I will be keeping it. However - it will not come out right for me. I am building a starter, and it’s very nearly strong enough for making sourdough, so I don’t think that’s the problem, but my loaves just will not spring! I have let it rise for one hour, and then, the next try, for two hours. But the results are the same; dense, doughy, no additional rising in the oven at all. Any suggestions?

  30. I am wanting to use discard, should it be at room temp, or can I use it right out of the fridge?

  31. 5 stars
    I tried this recipe the other day and the bread came out wonderful! I baked mine 20 minutes with the lid on and 30 minutes without the lid in the dutch oven at 450 degrees F. I am planning on making again tomorrow. Thank you for the recipe!

  32. This turned out great! made the first two slices into garlic toast. Thanks for the recipe and detailed instructions!

  33. 5 stars
    Excellent recipe, very tasty bread and extremely easy to make. Had a lot of discard from my starter, so I doubled it in the recipe, decreasing the amount of water and flour accordingly. Absolute keeper, thank you!!!

  34. Thank you for all the great information. For the discard bread recipe, can I make it in the Zojirushi bread maker?

  35. 5 stars
    My family of 6 eagerly waited around the table as I pulled this bread out. Everyone heartily approved and first loaf is mostly gone. Good thing I had enough discard for a second loaf!
    I love the speed of this bread. My house was a bit warm (and maybe my discard was in good shape.) Only took 45 minutes to rise. This one's a keeper!

  36. Just wondering what the oven time would be if I halved my dough to make two smaller loaves, baked separately. Thank you so much for this recipe, I love it.

  37. I doubled the recipe and I have half in the oven and the other half in the fridge. Once I remove the other half off the fridge do I need to let it rise again? I was planning on baking it tomorrow.
    Thanks!

  38. 5 stars
    I make all the time. I have done cinnamon and raisins and cranberry and walnuts as well as olive and rosemary and cheddar and jalapeño. For fruit breads I add 1/4 cup sugar. They love them.

  39. 5 stars
    Look no further!!!
    This bread recipe is IT. It cannot get any easier.
    I’m new to bread making, and have been using my homemade sourdough starter for a few months now. I love allll the ways I can use the discard - but was needing something new (and honestly just wanted more bread out of it!)
    This recipe has been my go to for weeks now. I make it in double batches, eat it all… or gift one to a neighbor or friend haha.
    After trying a few different discard recipes - this one has been the best tasting and looking. And it’s basically committed to my memory now. Thank you thank you!!

  40. This is a good recipe for a quick baked sandwich or toast type of bread. I'm familiar enough with working with higher hydration doughs to handle it and was able to score it quite easily. I'd agree with the suggestion of upping the off-lid baking portion for another 10-20 minutes (For a total baking time of 30 with lid and 20-30 off-lid). My bread was still a little "wet" after more than two hours of resting (and 15 minutes of off lid) so if I were to use this recipe again, I'd do just what I am suggesting. I was able to score and had a beautiful looking crusty exterior. Thanks

  41. 5 stars
    This is a fantastic bread recipe. I have made it several times (I’ve failed at making successful sourdough several times, so I have had a lot of discard over the past year), and this is probably the easiest bread recipe I have ever baked. My family and neighbors all rave about it.
    I have baked it in both a cast iron Dutch oven and regular loaf pans. If you are using loaf pans, make sure you put a water bath on the bottom rack of your oven to help create the steam that the inside of a Dutch oven creates.
    If you want to add to this recipe, I have found that thinly sliced garlic and 100g of garlic salt (instead of the 100g regular salt) is a popular loaf. My family also loves the “everything bagel” seasoning mixed into the dough. Today I’m trying this recipe with cinnamon and brown sugar.
    A very easy, versatile, recipe for utilizing discard and not throwing it away!
    Thank you so much for creating and publishing this recipe!

  42. 5 stars
    I have just taken our second loaf in 24 hours of this recipe out of the oven to cool, while a third loaf rises on the counter.

    My first loaf was tasty but a bit gummy, I think I likely didn’t allow the bread to rise enough and most importantly, I didn’t give my oven the full 30-45 minutes to preheat with the Dutch oven in it.

    I fixed these issues with the second loaf, can’t wait to see how it turned out!

  43. I really want to make a soft seeded rye bread, I am wondering if I add 150g rye and drop bread flour to 300g do you think I will need to adjust water? Ian
    Also going to add in caraway seeds. Should I add them when first mixing the dough? Thank you for making this easy!

    1. I cannot seem to get a sourdough loaf right no matter what I do:( after this doubled in size it was so loose and sticky. I still put it in the oven. Hoping for the best👍

  44. 5 stars
    I've made this bread twice now and I'm about to make it a third. I use double the starter and adjust water and flour as my starter is on the younger side and I want that sourdough taste. It turns out so well! I have subbed half flour for whole wheat and it made a wonderfully hearty (but still moist!) bread. I also added olives the second time around and that worked out great. Thanks for the recipe!

  45. 5 stars
    Made this recipe twice already and wow its so so good! Especially considering the minimal effort going into it. Quick question: the top part of my crust turned out perfectly crispy but the bottom crust was verrry hard for me both times. Like can't slice all the way down, almost break your teeth kinda crispy/hard. Is this normal? Or is there something could do to prevent this? (Maybe its an issue with my Dutch oven?) The rest of the bread was beautiful and delicious btw!

    1. Not totally sure I will get this right but are you using foil or putting the bread directly on the stove? If you are, it may be that, and you could try using parchment. If not, I'd wonder what vessel you're using and if you are taking the bread directly out of the vessel after it's dont baking. Usually with this loaf my bottoms soften up, and I tend to leave them on the stone for a while after they're done. Hope this helps!

  46. 5 stars
    I made the bread this morning, and it was absolutely delicious! I just started on the second loaf to bake it in the morning and take it over to a friend alongside with a stick of salter butter and some strawberry freezer jam

    Thank you for sharing this recipe!

    1. 5 stars
      This recipe has become my go to for a quick bread and to use down my discard. I'm curious, do you have a recommendation for the desired dough temperature for this bread?

  47. 4 stars
    I baked this and the bread turned out a lot more dense than I expected! Perhaps because I tried (and didn't succeed very well) to fold during the bulk proofing.
    I live in Singapore too do you think that affects it? Heat humidity et al. I stuck it into the fridge for a few hours before the bake and tried to shape it after before putting in the oven but it was still a sticky mess. Just curious to know why - overproofed?
    but on the bright side, it rose, and it uses up starter discard, yay! Thanks for the recipe!

  48. I received a sourdough starter for Christmas and was so afraid of it. After 2 failed attempts of making sourdough in my bread maker (following a recipe and using a 20+ year old bread maker), I found this recipe and made it! It was beautiful and easy and so wonderful!

    Thank you!

  49. 5 stars
    Absolutely love this recipe, probably made it 5-10 times now, a perfect "lazy loaf" for when you're not in the full-on sourdough baking mood!
    One thing I've wondered about is if you let it rise again after shaping it. The instructions aren't super clear on that: do you give it another rise before throwing it in the oven or are you letting the oven come up to temp while the dough is in its bulk rise, then shaping it and throwing it directly in the oven? I've done it both ways and haven't paid enough attention to know if it's better either way. Also, this is a no-knead recipe, yeah?
    Thanks for this!

  50. This is a great recipe!! When using only one oven, what is the baking time when baking two loaves of this bread in their individual dutch ovens at the same time? The recipe is soooo good that I have to make more than one at a time in my oven.

  51. 5 stars
    By far, the ugliest, stickiest, glopiest (New Word) bread dough ever!!!! I was 100% certain it would be a disaster. I am so glad I was wrong. I loved it, too easy and I’ve been trying to get my bread to be a little more airy and this recipe did it for me. Probably the very best part, I was able to use The Pantry Mama recipe for Sourdough Discard Sandwich Loaf and make them almost simultaneously. The loaf was also a WINNER.

  52. I think I’ve been reading this recipe wrong although the bread has always worked out and been delicious. But in my other sourdough recipes I let the pan in the oven for 45 minutes to an hour before I put the dough into it and bake is that correct? Or I’m just preheating the oven with the pan in it and then I’m good to go?

  53. 5 stars
    Yay!!! I finally made a good sourdough bread! Thank you. I didn’t have bread flour so I just used all purpose. It doubled in just about an hour (it’s about 74 degrees in my house). In the oven, it didn’t seem to rise as much as yours in the picture, but it is still delicious and near perfect consistancy!! (Others I’ve made have been too dense) I was getting too impatient and made it about 40 min into cooling before taking a taste.

  54. I can't wait to try this. I am traveling and her in Mexico the stove is propane. I think because there is not enough pressure, the highest I can get my temp is 350°F (177°C)
    Do you have any SD recipes besides the sandwich loaf that I can cook on lower heat. Or suggestions on what to do? Thanks.

  55. 5 stars
    Love this recipe! It has all the flavor of my artisan overnight bread but in a couple of hours!! Genius!
    One question: do you think I could cut down the amount of yeast added? I use rapid rise, and it really RISES! I don’t know that much about bread, so I thought I’d check in. Thank you.

  56. is it possible to do a regular sourdough bread recipe and just substitute discard for some of the flour and water?

    1. ...meaning using sourdough starter recipe (no commercial yeast) but using discard instead of some of the flour/water

  57. Can I make the sourdough discard bread with regular active dry yeast instead of instant or rapid yeast?

  58. 5 stars
    Thankyou thankyou!
    I didn't trust the process of making starter... So I kept starting new ones while I waited, and then they all started maturing at the same time 🙃
    I must say I couldn't bring myself to throw out the discard and my fridge was being over taken. This recipe allowed me to use it up and make delicious bread that everyone wants!
    So easy! now that I am starting to get creative with all types of inclusions this recipe definitely steps up every time!

  59. 5 stars
    This is such a good recipe. I can’t even count how many times I’ve made it. Here’s how I usually do it:
    Make the night before I want it, let it rise until I’m ready to go to bed then pop in the fridge. In the morning I put it on floured parchment paper, pull in the sides to shape, then flip it and score it. Then put it all inside a hot Dutch oven and spray some water on the top of the bread, cover it and bake according to the recipe. SO good!

  60. I used Chrome, then tried again in Safari, and when I click the "Print Recipe" hyperlink it opens a new tab with the same webpage instead of a simple page that prints just the recipe. Just wanted you to know more than one person is having an issue with that link. I'd also love to be able to print it instead of needing to keep my phone running 🙂

  61. I'm new at your website and excited to try your recipes. But is there a way that you can give the U.S measurements to cups instead of grams? I've tried looking for conversions online but they seem to be different, so I don't really know which one is accurate.

  62. 4 stars
    I just made this bread the other day and it is so good! I stepped away from my dough for about two hours and I guess the kitchen was hot because my dough doubled and pushed outside the plastic wrap haha! The only diffuculty I had was the stickiness of the dough. I also made a lousy choice to use wax paper instead of true parchment paper which totally stuck to my entire loaf. It still tastes great even with the pape, though!

  63. 5 stars
    Curious about why the hydration level of this recipe is 75%?. My starter is always 1:1. I guess the high hydration is so the mix can be stirred up and no kneading? Also, using unfed, immature discard in a bread recipe, is the flour spent already and won't provide enough food for the yeast in the bread dough if counting the amount of flour and water in a discard as a part of bread recipe. Say, a recipe calls for 400g flour, 60% hydration. I'd use 100g discard, 1:1. 350g flour, 190g water. The amount of flour and water in the discard at 1:1 makes up the total of 240g water:400g flour. Thank you for all your help.

  64. 5 stars
    Thank you so much for this awesome recipe! I followed the recipe to a 'T' and everyone was pouring on the compliments as to how delicious it tasted. This is definitely my favorite recipe as it is also very easy and quick. Will be baking bread with this recipe and will add other goodies. Thank you again!

  65. 4 stars
    I'm struggling with the texture of this bread. I've now made it about 5 different times. It always ends up a little gummy (not underbaked). I've done it where it doubles or even triples, but it always ends up less cakey more gummy looking. It's shiny inside. Is that right? It's delicious when toasted, just chewy when untoasted.

  66. Hi! Why do you need a glass or ceramic bowl? Is a plastic bowl fine too? Also my dough doesn't really seem to double in size, not after an hour and not after 2,5 hours. Am I doing something wrong? I don't want to wait too long so it doesn't rise in the oven anymore. It just grows a tiny bit.

    1. I prefer to use glass as I can see what's happening underneath the surface of the dough 🙂

      1. 5 stars
        How much starter would you use to replace the instant yeast? Does the rest of the recipe/directions stay the same?

  67. Of the 7-8 times I've made it, this last one was the BEST:
    115 g Sourdough Discard unfed sourdough starter (Three weeks old, totally unfed, slightly starving judging from the slight vinegary smell)
    400g acid whey (three to four weeks old, from Greek yogurt making)
    11 g Fine Sea Salt
    10 g Rapid Yeast (for Bread Machine)
    50g wheat bran
    450 g Bread Flour
    1 hour rising outside on porch, covered with dish towel, at about 30-32 Celsius
    Scored with kitchen shears
    Convection oven, single rack covered in big hard-anodized Dutch oven on parchment paper, 430F for 45 minutes (I forgot I had it in the oven!)
    Then 390F uncovered for 10 minutes.
    I find it is a somewhat forgiving recipe, and it is always a big hit, but this was on a different level.

  68. 5 stars
    Oh my gosh! This is a wonderful, easy bread and ready sooooooo quick! I’m making risotto and shrimp tonight for dinner and needed a bread to go with it. I didn’t plan ahead to make a full-on sourdough artisan bread and just happened upon this recipe this morning. I had plenty of discard on hand, so I decided at the spur of the moment to make this recipe. I am so glad I did! It has beautiful texture and crumb. The holes are perfect! Not overly sour, which my hubby prefers, although I’m working on him to learn to love sourdough as much as I do! Thank you, Kate, for this great quick recipe!!!!!

  69. 5 stars
    Just wanted to add that I did some coil folds every 30 minutes for the first 2 hours (just like a standard naturally leavened dough) and it pulled together very nicely! Was able to shape no problem and it is in the fridge now so I can score it cold in the AM and bake it. Hoping it comes out great, it looks promising!

  70. 5 stars
    Made this bread today from 8 day discard. Very pleased with the taste! My bread was a teeny bit dense and think it could have used another 5-10 minutes more on the bake. Like others, I had a difficult time with scoring. Read your tip for using scissors to accomplish this. Will
    use scissors next time. Overall, a dynamite sourdough loaf!

  71. 5 stars
    I LOVE THIS RECIPE. Of the about 12-15 times I've made it with different flours, proportions, times, the following was the BEST:
    About 125-129 g unfed about a month old refrigerated sourdough starter
    A little over 400g acid whey from homemade Greek yogurt
    11 g Instant Yeast
    Mixed first and left for a while to come to room temp. Didn't really bubble but almost.
    In a separate bowl:
    12 g Salt
    50g wheat bran
    30 g ground flaxseed
    About 210 g whole wheat flour then completed with bread flour to a total of 450 g flour. Mixed dry ingredients well, then mixed the wet ingredients in with a Danish whisk (super helpful).
    About 2 hours rising inside, covered with dish towel, at about 22-23 celsius
    Then overnight in the fridge.
    Next morning when oven ready at 430F, folded about 12 times over rice flour, made a firm ball, scored with bread lame in square top + heart
    Baked covered in hard-anodized Dutch oven on parchment paper, 430F for 38 minutes
    Then 390F uncovered for 15 minutes. I wish I could post a picture. The most beautiful loaf, and the tastiest.

  72. 5 stars
    To anyone asking about doubling the recipe to make 1 large loaf. Works great. I did cook it for 35 minutes with lid on, then 20 minutes with lid off. Nice and crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle

  73. 5 stars
    Delicious! I added cheddar and jalapeños. I used a 5 qt dutch oven and the loaf spread a little too much since it’s so wet. What size Dutch oven do you recommend?

  74. 5 stars
    I've been wanting to try making sourdough bread, but have been having trouble just jumping in, so when I came across this recipe I decided to try it, since it's a lot easier process. I don't have a Dutch oven but decided to wing it. Apart from the dough being very wet and sticky, it was very easy to make the dough. I adjusted the cooking temperature and time to compensate for the lack of Dutch oven, it was on about 190C for an hour. I'd thought I would put a tray of water in the bottom of the oven to create some steam, but I forgot to do that, and I was sure it was going to be a brick. Turned out perfect! I was so pleased! Will definitely be making this recipe again!

  75. 5 stars
    This is my go to recipe!! My family loves this recipe as much as I do!! Thank you so much for sharing ♥️ I love all of your recipes and will continue to learn from them!!

  76. 5 stars
    This was the easiest, yummiest bread to make!!! I made one as the recipe states, one jalapeno cheddar, one rosemary Parmesan and one garlic and they are all AMAZING!!!! This is the bread of my dreams! Thank you Pantry Mama!!!!

  77. 5 stars
    Made once and turned out wet and gummy but still delicious! Trying again but without the give or take in measuring! Question, does it have to double before placing in fridge, or can it double in fridge?! Added some garlic salt this go around! The anticipation is killer to taste this time!
    Thank you <3

  78. 5 stars
    This is the best and easiest sourdough I’ve ever tried! I follow the recipe exactly and it comes out perfect every time.

  79. 5 stars
    I love this recipe! I’ve made it twice and the taste is so delicious. The only thing is that I’m not getting as high of a rise like the photos you posted. Any recommendations? The second time I made it I definitely let it proof for 2 hours which did give it some more height compared to my 1st one. I also used regular flour - would bread flour help it rise more? Thanks in advance!

  80. 5 stars
    Wow! This is going to be one of my forever recipes! I used white whole wheat and semolina instead of white flour (added two tablespoons of gluten to strengthen the protein content) and threw in cinnamon, walnuts and unsweetened cranberries. It was easy to score and the rise and crumb were perfect. Thanks so much for this wonderful recipe!

  81. 5 stars
    I work from home and this recipe requires so little interaction that I mixed it, shaped and baked it during my workday! It was never more than 5 minutes in the kitchen at any step. I added sliced green olives and cheddar cheese and dusted the top with Italian herbs and black pepper. WOW. The ease and lack of intervention time belied the result, which is excellent! I am making a sweet loaf today and have already offered to make a "custom flavor" loaf for my sister. Glad to have found this - thank you!

    1. 5 stars
      I truly thought I ruined the dough when I let it rise for like 6 hours, but I honestly did a bunch of stretch and folds with some flour and baked it according to the recipe and it came out gorgeous.

  82. 5 stars
    What if I accidentally over proofed it? Can it be saved? I tried the punch down and let it rerise method but that is happening real slow...

  83. 5 stars
    I made this recipe today with Bobs Redmill Gluten Free Bread Flour and it turned out amazing! Was too sticky to score, but turned out beautifully and tasty! Thank you for the great recipe!

  84. 5 stars
    I am a beginner with sourdough starter and I have struggled with making sourdough bread but this recipe was so straight forward and easy to make! My husband keeps requesting i make more and bringing into work to share with everyone. Its a hit!

  85. 5 stars
    Love this recipe! We have made this bread several times just with organic white bread flour and an artesan all-purpose flour and every time it turned out great. Wondering if anyone has incorporated wheat bran as I have a huge bag of it I need to use. Should we be able to substitute some bran for some flour, or just add it to the mix?

  86. 5 stars
    Thank you for the best recipe EVER!! I’ve made it several times with aged white cheddar and pepper jack cheese and and it’s always gone within a day! No other food sounds good to my family of 3 when this bread is sitting on the counter! All the friends and family request it when visiting! If I split the recipe in half do you know if the oven instructions would stay the same?

    1. I'm so glad you love the recipe! Ooooh and those inclusions sound amazing! Yes same oven instructions, even if you split it in half 🙂 xx

  87. Can you use more then 100G of discard, I'm thinking of around 125G. Love this recipe and have made it several times, however I have a fair bit of discard and wanted to use it up.
    Thank you
    Marc

  88. 4 stars
    Made this yesterday! So yummy. Wasn’t expecting much cause the dough was very floppy. Surprised how it turned out. Thank you for sharing 👍

  89. 5 stars
    What a phenomenal consolation prize for my starter that has been slumping! Thanks for helping me bake my very first loaf of bread. It turned out PERFECT and I'm never buying one at the grocery store again 😛 Soft and springy inside, crunchy outside, beautiful, elegant, simple... the best!

  90. 5 stars
    I love this recipe! You really can't go wrong with it. I fell asleep and left it for about three hours, then it had to go in the fridge for a couple more hours as I had to rush out. I baked it anyway, and it's soft and delicious, and the kids both love it.

  91. 5 stars
    I just got back into sourdough and bread making. I was looking for some way to use my discard and found this recipe. I love it. Not super sour but it's so good. Could I omit the yeast and use my active starter? This is also the first loaf I used my long forgotten pampered chef stone Dutch oven. OMG. I think you said it was a game changer, it really is. I made focaccia last night and it was very good and I made I think it is your simple bread recipe and it didn't rise and it was a rock. No Dutch oven, only a loaf pan. learned my lesson. 🙂

  92. Looking forward to trying your recipe, I usually do 6g yeast, 200g discard, 400 flour, and 270 water w/ 25g honey. Also a few stretch and folds in the first hour and a half, after an hr rest. Curious to see results, thanks again.

  93. 5 stars
    So easy and so good!! I feel like it's totally fool proof. I "messed up" several stops on the way - added a little too much starter, added a little too much flour, over proofed, used cold water by mistake, etc. - and it still came out amazing. So chewy and flavorful!

  94. 5 stars
    All I can say is WOW!! I had so much discard on hand and was overwhelmed with other recipes. Your recipe was super simple and QUICK! After removing it from the Dutch oven, I brushed some butter on top. I will be making this again and sharing the recipe!

  95. I made this on a whim to have with fresh chanterelle mushroom soup and it turned out amazing!!! Thanks for sharing this recipe I’ll definitely use it again.

  96. Hello. I made your Easy Sourdough Discard Bread. I followed your instructions and then put the dough in the fridge in one bowl covered. the next morning I took out the dough and let it warm up for about 45 minutes. I then separated the dough into 2 loaves .I let that sit for about 30 min., then proceeded to bake. The loaves did not rise up. Should I have separated the bread into 2 loaves and covered them and put in the fridge? Also if I wanted to make the dough at night and bake in the morning how would you proceed with the preheating of cast iron dutch oven? thank you leland. PS. Made your Discard Crackers used grated Parmesan and cracked pepperoni sesame seeds on one batch and farm,cracked pepper and fresh rosemary on the other, very good. we ate too many the first day. thank you for your Recipes

  97. 5 stars
    Yay, I successfully made this discard bread, tasted scrumptious. I am going to make it again tomorrow as I will have instant yeast and not just plain yeast. Thanks for the recipe.

  98. 5 stars
    At first i was like i am not sure why yeast is in there . Doing research discard is more about flavor than rise. A few things i did do that wasn't listen i did 2 stretch and folds 30 min apart to help establish gluten and to be more manageable. I don't have an option for 430f degrees, so i just did 425f degree i baked closed lid for 45 min and baked uncovered for 15 til golden brown. I waited an hour to slice in , still had the sourdough flavor not to sour perfect combination. it was soft not gummy . loved it . and the spring on it was beyond beautiful. I did pop it in my freezer for 15 min before scoring my loaf .

  99. 3 stars
    Hello, wondering if you do store in the fridge, what is the process after. Do we fold and stretch? Or just plop it out on some flour on a counter and try to shape and then bake ? Do I need to leave it out to get to room temp or wait for it to rise if it does rise ?

  100. 5 stars
    This recipe is my favorite bread recipe! It’s awsome! I have a question about the Calorie count, that can’t be 1647k as in 1,647,000 calories? Is the added k a mistake?

    1. Hi Sarah, Though it seems deceiving, kilocalories and calories are the same thing, and used interchangeably. It's 1,647 kcal or 1,647 calories. 🙂

  101. 5 stars
    Made this last night in my cast iron and it is SOOOOOO delicious. Had it with homemade chicken/rice soup. Pairs so good together and I definitely plan on making it again!!!

  102. 5 stars
    Made this today. Followed the recipe and it turned out techange.
    A nice tender crumb.

    I'm at 7000 feet and made no changes for the first try, but will add another gram or two of salt as high altitude just needs that for flavor.

    Next time I will put in the fridge to see how the flavors change.

  103. 5 stars
    I love this recipe - I've been baking this bread at least once a week since I started growing my starter, and it's one of the best. Thank you 🤩

  104. 5 stars
    I love this recipe I always do and is so practical! I have a question, can i cut in two loafs ? If yes, for how long? The same time?

  105. I used all purpose flour. I didn’t have the pockets of air in my bread it was more dense. First time, so I don’t know if that’s normal. It also looked doughy on the outside once done, not browned. Any suggestions what I could have done differently?

  106. 5 stars
    First off great bread recipe! Do you think you could split this into 2 smaller loaves? & What the cook time would be? Thank you

  107. 5 stars
    This recipe works! I thought it looked too simple to make nice bread but we like the finished product a lot. I think it might need a bit more of a rise in my kitchen (revision for next time I try it). I plan to try a rye version next.

  108. 1 star
    It seemed like a great idea to add yeast, so I gave this one a try yesterday. Another failure. Heavy, dense loaf. Not well browned. I have been baking sourdough for close to a year and my loaves in Michigan were quite nice; big and fluffy with a nice crust. Then we came back to Florida for Winter Season and I haven't had a successful loaf since. I've been working on my starter since the last week of November - so that's coming up to a month and still not a single loaf has been IMHO worth eating. I'm trying the 'cold from the fridge' method this morning so we'll see if that gets better results.